Key takeaways
- Run the full checklist twice a year and the short version monthly; most phone failures come from changes nobody reviewed.
- Check every published number end to end, including the ones on old directory listings and review sites.
- Difficulty contacting the firm is a recognised barrier to complaining for 16% of conveyancing clients, so access problems hide complaints rather than prevent them[1].
- Recording and call data are personal data: set retention periods and know the 72-hour breach reporting rule[2].
- If you publish reviews, you need reasonable steps against fake ones and a clear review policy[3].
How to use this checklist
Phones drift. A new partner gets a direct dial that bypasses reception, a merger leaves an old number ringing in an empty office, a holiday greeting stays up until March. None of these is a crisis on its own, but together they decide whether clients can reach you. The Legal Ombudsman found evidence of poor service in 72% of the complaints it assessed in 2025/26, rising to 79% in wills and probate and 78% in residential conveyancing[4].
The checklist below is split into seven areas. Work through all of them twice a year, ideally before the busy spring and autumn periods, and pick out the starred items for a ten-minute monthly check. Give each area a named owner. The practice manager usually owns the whole list, but the IT provider, the reception lead and the compliance officer each own parts of it.
1. Numbers, listings and greetings
- Starred: call every published number from an outside mobile and check it rings where it should, at the time of day clients use it.
- Search for the firm on maps, directories and review sites and list every number shown. Remove or redirect old ones.
- Check the number on your website matches letterheads, email signatures, the client care letter and the complaints procedure.
- Listen to every greeting and out-of-hours message. Do they give the firm name, opening hours and what to do in an emergency?
- Starred: remove any seasonal or temporary message that has outlived its purpose.
- Make sure the website shows your SRA number and the SRA digital badge, which SRA-authorised firms must display[5].
2. Routing, cover and opening hours
- Starred: confirm who answers each line on every day this month, including the backup when someone is away.
- Map what happens to a call unanswered after a set number of rings. It should never ring out, and never go to a full or unchecked voicemail.
- Check direct dials. If a fee earner is out, does the call fall back to their team or to reception?
- Review lunchtime and end-of-day cover against your call logs; see our guide to peak call times.
- Test your urgent route: how does an out-of-hours caller with an arrest, injunction or completion problem reach someone?
- Confirm that menus are short. Two or three options are enough for most firms; long menus make callers hang up.
3. Messages and call-backs
- Starred: sample ten messages left last month. Was each returned, and within the time promised?
- Check messages include the caller's name, number, matter, reason and any deadline, in a consistent format.
- Make sure every message reaches a shared queue as well as the individual, so nothing is lost when someone is ill.
- Set a firm-wide call-back standard and put it in your client care information so expectations are clear.
- Check fee earners clear their voicemail daily, or turn personal voicemail off in favour of a team message route.
Unreturned calls are where many complaints begin. In 2025/26, 25% of consumers told the Legal Ombudsman they had not received a final response from their provider to their complaint[4]. A firm that cannot return ordinary calls reliably is unlikely to handle complaints well either.
4. Recording, data and security
- Confirm the recorded message and privacy notice tell callers when and why calls are recorded.
- Check the retention period set in the phone system matches your policy, and that old recordings are actually deleted.
- Limit who can listen to recordings, and review the access list when people join or leave.
- Starred: check that former staff no longer have phone system logins or app access on personal devices.
- Know what to do if call data is exposed. A reportable personal data breach must be notified to the ICO without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours of becoming aware of it[2].
- Check how texts and voicemails are stored and whether they reach the matter file; our note on texting clients covers this.
5. Accessibility and language
- Every receptionist knows how to handle a Relay UK call and how to call back with the 18002 prefix; see our guide to accessible phone contact.
- The website offers an email or form route as well as a phone number.
- You know how to book spoken-language and BSL interpreters at short notice.
- Firms in Wales have a written approach to Welsh-language calls and call-backs.
- Preferred contact method and any adjustments are recorded where the next person handling the client will see them.
6. Quality and reporting
Keep the monthly report short enough that partners read it. One page with a handful of measures, compared with last month and the same month last year, is plenty.
| Measure | Where it comes from | Review |
|---|---|---|
| Calls offered and answered, by line | Phone system | Monthly |
| Unanswered calls at the busiest half-hours | Phone system | Monthly |
| Messages returned within the promised time | Message log sample | Monthly |
| New enquiries and consultations booked | Case management or enquiry log | Monthly |
| Average reception call score | Quality monitoring | Monthly |
| Complaints mentioning contact or communication | Complaints register | Quarterly |
| Phone system costs and contract dates | Supplier invoices | Twice a year |
Use the scores from your call quality monitoring for the quality line, and check that custody and urgent calls are being handled to the standard in our guide to calls from prisons and immigration centres.
7. Reviews and reputation
Phone experience shows up in online reviews, and some clients check them: 14% of people choosing a main adviser searched for reviews[6]. If your firm publishes or displays reviews, consumer law now applies directly. Since April 2025, businesses that publish consumer reviews must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake reviews, and the CMA says they should have a published policy prohibiting fake reviews and setting out their approach to incentivised ones[3].
- Check whether your website shows reviews, and if so, that a review policy is published alongside them.
- Never write, commission or reward reviews in a way that hides the incentive.
- Read recent reviews monthly for mentions of phones, call-backs or rudeness, and feed them into coaching.
- Reply to critical reviews politely and without confirming that the reviewer is or was a client.
Suppliers, contracts and continuity
- List every phone supplier, contract end date and notice period, so renewals are a decision rather than an automatic roll-over.
- Check who at the firm holds the admin login for the phone system, and that at least two people can make urgent routing changes.
- Confirm what happens if the internet connection or the office fails: can calls divert to mobiles or another office within minutes?
- Test the divert once a year, out of hours, and time how long it takes.
- Make sure out-of-hours or overflow providers have your current urgent-contact list and escalation rules.
- Keep a one-page diagram of your numbers and routing with the business continuity plan.
The monthly check need not take long. Ring the main numbers from a mobile, glance at the unanswered-call figures for the busiest half-hours, sample the message log, read new reviews and confirm cover for the coming month. If anything fails, add it to the next partners' report with a named owner and a date, and check it is fixed before the following month's check. Over a year, the small monthly fixes usually do more than the six-monthly review.
Example: a six-monthly check in practice
Example: the practice manager at a fictional ten-solicitor firm spends a morning on the full checklist. She finds an old branch number still listed on two directory sites, ringing a handset nobody answers; a partner's direct dial with voicemail full since the summer; and a recorded greeting that still mentions Covid arrangements. The call logs show the lunchtime slot losing about one call in six.
The fixes take a week: the old number is redirected to reception, personal voicemail is replaced with a team message route, the greeting is re-recorded and lunches are staggered. None of it needed new technology. The next quarter's complaints register has no complaints mentioning difficulty getting through, and the monthly report now shows unanswered lunchtime calls falling. The same discipline helps when instructions come in by phone, covered in taking instructions by phone safely.
Frequently asked questions
How often should we review our phone set-up?
Run a full review twice a year and a short monthly check of the starred items. Also review after any office move, merger, new practice area or phone system change.
Who should own phone operations in a law firm?
Usually the practice manager, with named owners for IT, reception and compliance tasks. What matters is that each item on the checklist has one person accountable for it.
Do we need a policy if we show client reviews on our website?
Yes. Businesses publishing consumer reviews must take reasonable steps against fake reviews, and the CMA expects a published policy that prohibits fake reviews and explains the approach to incentivised ones.
What should partners see each month?
A one-page summary: calls offered and answered by line, unanswered calls at peak times, call-backs returned on time, enquiries booked, quality scores and any complaints about contact.
References
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 33: Notification of a personal data breach to the supervisory authority (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Transparency Rules (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑