Phones and call handling

Taking instructions by phone safely

What a solicitor should confirm on a call before treating it as instructions: identity, authority, capacity, conflicts, scope and costs.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Phone instructions are normal, which is why they go wrong
  2. The five checks before you act
  3. A call protocol fee earners can follow
  4. High-risk instructions that need more than a call
  5. Costs and complaints still need writing
  6. File notes that hold up later
  7. Example: the daughter who calls about her mother's will
  8. Where the first call is not answered by a fee earner
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • The telephone is the most common way people deal with their main legal adviser on a contentious issue, so phone instructions are normal, not a shortcut[1].
  • Before acting, confirm five things: who the client is, that they are the person instructing, that they can instruct, that there is no conflict, and what exactly they want done.
  • Identity checks under the Money Laundering Regulations must rest on reliable, independent documents or a secure electronic process, not on a voice[2].
  • Costs and complaints information must reach the client in writing at engagement, whatever was said on the call[3].
  • Close every instruction call with a read-back and a same-day written confirmation.

Phone instructions are normal, which is why they go wrong

Most firms take instructions by phone every day. In the Legal Services Board's Legal Needs Survey, the telephone was the most common way people communicated with their main adviser on a contentious issue, slightly ahead of face to face and email[1]. Pricing conversations also happen by phone: 63% of consumers first found out the price of their legal service through a discussion with the provider[4].

How people communicated with their main adviser on a contentious issueAdults in England and Wales, Legal Needs Survey 2023
How people communicated with their main adviser on a contentious issueBar chart. Telephone: 28%; Face to face: 27%; Email: 24%.TelephoneTelephone: 28%28%Face to faceFace to face: 27%27%EmailEmail: 24%24%How people communicated with their main adviser on a contentious issueBar chart. Telephone: 28%; Face to face: 27%; Email: 24%.TelephoneTelephone: 28%28%Face to faceFace to face: 27%27%EmailEmail: 24%24%

Source: Legal Services Board, 2024[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Telephone28%
Face to face27%
Email24%

Because phone instructions are routine, the checks get skipped. A familiar voice, a busy afternoon and an urgent request are the conditions in which a firm acts for the wrong person, beyond its authority or on terms the client never understood. The problems surface later as complaints about costs, delay and poor information, which the Legal Ombudsman says are the most common complaints it resolves[5].

The five checks before you act

A call is not instructions until you can answer yes to each of these. Some can be done during the call; others need a document or a second conversation.

What must be true before a call becomes instructions
CheckQuestionHow to confirm
IdentityIs the caller who they say they are?Existing client: security questions against the file and a call back on the number held. New client: ID documents or a secure electronic check before you act.
AuthorityAre they entitled to give these instructions?Joint clients both confirm. Companies: a director or authorised officer. Attorneys and deputies: see the power or order.
Capacity and free willCan they make this decision, and is it their own?Speak to the client alone. Watch for confusion, pressure or a third party answering for them.
ConflictCan the firm act?Run the conflict search on every party named before giving advice.
ScopeWhat exactly are we being asked to do?Read back the task, the deadline and any limits in plain words.

For new clients the identity point is not optional. The Money Laundering Regulations 2017 require you to identify the customer and verify their identity on the basis of documents or information from a reliable, independent source, which can include a secure electronic identification process[2]. A voice on the phone is neither.

A call protocol fee earners can follow

  1. Open the file before the call, or as it starts

    Have the matter, the client's contact details and any notes on vulnerability or preferred contact method in front of you.

  2. Confirm identity

    Ask two questions only the client would know from the file, such as a reference number and the date of the last letter. Do not read details out for them to agree with.

  3. Find out who else is listening

    Ask whether anyone is with them. If a relative or adviser is on the line, ask the client to confirm they are happy for that person to hear the discussion.

  4. Let the client state the instruction

    Use open questions: "What would you like us to do?" rather than "So you want us to accept the offer?"

  5. Explain the consequences

    Say what the step means, what it will cost if that changes the estimate, and whether it can be undone.

  6. Read it back

    "So, to confirm: you want us to accept the offer of settlement on the terms in their letter of 3 March, and to tell the other side today. Is that right?"

  7. Confirm in writing the same day

    Send a short email or letter recording the instruction, the date and time of the call and anything you advised. Ask the client to reply if anything is wrong.

Use the same order on every call so it becomes habit. When reception takes the first call rather than a fee earner, the rules in our reception guide for custody calls and our Welsh-language call notes still apply.

High-risk instructions that need more than a call

Some instructions should never be acted on from a call alone, however well you know the client. Agree a firm-wide list and put it in your office manual.

  • Any change to bank details for sending money out, which is the classic payment diversion fraud; confirm through a known number and in writing.
  • Accepting or rejecting a settlement offer, or withdrawing a claim.
  • Instructions to exchange contracts or complete a property transaction where anything has changed since the last written confirmation.
  • New or changed wills, gifts or powers of attorney, especially where a relative made the call.
  • Instructions from one joint client that affect the other.
  • Instructions that go beyond the scope in the client care letter.

A useful rule: if the instruction moves money, ends a dispute, changes who benefits or cannot be undone, confirm it in writing from the client before you act, not after.

Costs and complaints still need writing

Phone calls are where clients ask "How much will it cost?" and where the honest answer is often "It depends." The SRA Code of Conduct requires you to give clients the best possible information about how their matter will be priced and the likely overall cost, both at engagement and as the matter progresses[3]. It also requires clients to be told in writing at engagement about their right to complain[3].

So a costs estimate given on the phone must be followed by the same estimate in writing. If a new instruction on a call changes the scope, update the estimate in the confirmation email. Clients served mainly by phone were also more likely to say they would have liked more contact with a legal professional, 24% against 17% overall[6], so a clear written record is part of good service as well as compliance.

File notes that hold up later

If an instruction is ever disputed, the file note is your evidence. Notes written hours later from memory, or a single line saying "spoke to client, agreed", rarely help. Build a short template into your case management system so every phone instruction is recorded the same way.

  • Date, start time and length of the call, and who called whom.
  • How identity was confirmed, and who else was on the line.
  • The instruction in the client's words where possible, not your summary of it.
  • The advice you gave, including risks and alternatives you mentioned.
  • Any change to the costs estimate and whether the client accepted it.
  • Anything that suggested pressure, confusion or a need for a different approach.
  • What happens next, who will do it and by when.

Write the note before the next call, not at the end of the day. If you used a script or checklist, save it with the note so a supervisor can see which checks were done. A supervisor reviewing files once a month should be able to tell from the note alone whether the five checks were met. Where they were not, the fix is usually coaching on the protocol rather than a new form.

Example: the daughter who calls about her mother's will

Example: a woman calls a private client team to say her elderly mother wants to change her will to leave the house to her rather than split it between three children. She asks the firm to draft the change and post it for signature.

The fee earner takes the details but explains that the firm must take instructions from the mother directly and alone. She books a home visit, sends the mother a letter explaining the appointment, runs the conflict check and notes that the caller would benefit from the change. At the visit she speaks to the mother privately, checks her understanding and records her reasons. The will is changed, but on the mother's instructions, with a file note that would stand up if another child later challenged it.

Had the firm drafted from the daughter's call, it would have had no evidence the instructions were the mother's own. The cost of doing it properly was one visit.

Where the first call is not answered by a fee earner

Many first calls are taken by reception, an out-of-hours service or an AI employee. That is fine, provided whoever answers is clear that they are collecting information and booking, not taking instructions. Ava, for example, follows your approved intake questions and hands over a note; a solicitor then runs the five checks before anything is done. For training reception on the boundary, see our call quality monitoring scorecard and our guide to peak call times and staffing.

Make the boundary visible in the script. Reception should say "I will take the details and a solicitor will call you to discuss what you would like to do", never "I will tell them to go ahead."

Frequently asked questions

Can a solicitor accept instructions over the phone?

Yes. Phone instructions are common and valid, but you must still be sure who you are acting for, that they can instruct you and what they want, and you should confirm the instruction in writing promptly.

Is a phone call enough to verify a new client's identity?

No. The Money Laundering Regulations require verification on the basis of documents or information from a reliable, independent source, which can include a secure electronic identification process.

Should we record instruction calls?

Recording can help, but tell callers it happens and say why in your privacy notice. A recording does not replace a written confirmation sent to the client.

What if a relative calls to give instructions for a client?

Take their information, but get instructions from the client directly, ideally alone. Record why you were satisfied the instructions were the client's own.

References

  1. Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2017). The Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017, regulation 28 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Complaints we can help with (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo