Key takeaways
- Salary is only the start: employer National Insurance is 15% on earnings above the £5,000 secondary threshold in 2026/27[1].
- Statutory holiday of 5.6 weeks a year means someone else must answer the phone for more than a month of working days[2].
- In a worked example built on median pay, a full-time receptionist's true annual cost is about a third higher than the salary.
- Outsourced answering has its own hidden costs: set-up, script changes, overage, quality checks and lost instructions from weak notes.
- Compare like with like: a receptionist does far more than answer calls, so price the tasks, not the job title.
Why salary-versus-subscription is the wrong comparison
When a small solicitors firm weighs up reception, the comparison usually starts with two numbers: a salary from a job advert and a monthly fee from an answering service's website. Both are misleading on their own. The salary leaves out employer taxes, pension, holiday cover, recruitment and the management time a front desk takes. The fee leaves out set-up, overage, script changes and the hidden cost of messages your team cannot act on.
Staff are already the biggest cost in the sector. UK legal activities businesses spent £18.2 billion on employment costs in 2024, about 36% of turnover, according to the ONS Annual Business Survey[3]. Reception is a small slice of that, but it is the slice most firms review first when margins tighten, so it pays to do the sum properly.
36%
of UK legal activities turnover went on employment costs in 2024[3]
The full cost of an in-house receptionist
Start with official figures rather than job adverts. Median gross annual pay for full-time UK receptionists was £25,865 in 2026 (provisional), up 4.9% on the year[4]. To that, add the costs that come with employing anyone.
- Employer National Insurance: Class 1 secondary contributions at 15% on earnings above the £5,000-a-year secondary threshold in 2026/27[1]. Eligible employers can reduce their bill with the Employment Allowance, worth up to £10,500 in 2026/27[1], so check whether your firm already uses it up.
- Workplace pension: under automatic enrolment the minimum employer contribution is 3%, with a total minimum of 8%[5]. Many firms pay more.
- Holiday cover: most workers on a five-day week are entitled to at least 28 days' paid leave a year, the equivalent of 5.6 weeks[2]. Someone must answer the phone during those weeks.
- Sickness, training and lunch cover, which follow the same logic on a smaller scale.
- Recruitment and induction: advertising, interviews, references, and several weeks before a new starter handles calls confidently.
- Desk, equipment, phone licence and a share of office space.
- Management time: rotas, supervision, appraisals and covering problems when they arise.
Worked example: one full-time receptionist
Example: the figures below use the median salary and simplified assumptions so that the sum is easy to follow. Employer NIC is 15% of the salary above £5,000, which is £3,130. Pension is taken as 3% of the full salary for simplicity, £776; in practice the minimum applies to qualifying earnings, so your figure may be lower. Holiday cover assumes 28 days of seven and a half hours covered by a legal secretary at the median hourly rate of £14.95[4], which comes to £3,140 of time that legal secretary is not spending on their own work. Management time assumes one hour a week of a solicitor's time over 46 working weeks at the median solicitor hourly rate of £31.50[4], which is £1,449.
- Salary (median) £25,865 75%
- Employer NIC £3,130 9%
- Holiday cover time £3,140 9%
- Management time £1,449 4%
- Pension (3%) £776 2%
Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Salary (median) | £25,865 |
| Employer NIC | £3,130 |
| Holiday cover time | £3,140 |
| Management time | £1,449 |
| Pension (3%) | £776 |
On those assumptions, the true annual cost in the example is about £34,360 before recruitment, equipment, office space or sickness, roughly a third more than the salary alone. Your own numbers will differ: London salaries are higher, a part-time role changes the NIC position, and the Employment Allowance may absorb the employer NIC entirely in a very small firm. The method is what matters.
The full cost of outsourced answering
Answering services price in several ways: per call, per minute, in monthly bundles of calls or minutes, or as a flat fee for set hours. None is better in principle. What matters is how the structure fits your call pattern, and what sits outside the headline figure.
- Set-up and onboarding charges, including script writing.
- Overage when a busy month exceeds the bundle, which is common around stamp duty deadlines and after marketing pushes.
- Charges for script changes, extra departments or new numbers.
- Out-of-hours, weekend or bank holiday surcharges.
- Minimum terms and notice periods that make switching expensive.
- Internal time spent reviewing messages, correcting scripts and calling back people whose details were incomplete.
- The cost of instructions lost because a new caller was handled poorly or a note missed the deadline.
The last two are easy to ignore and often the largest. If one in ten notes needs a callback just to find out what the matter is, a fee earner or secretary is doing reception work anyway. If a weak greeting loses a conveyancing instruction a month, that one loss can outweigh the entire saving.
Costs that never appear on an invoice
Some of the most important costs sit on neither side of the obvious comparison. They show up as slower files, irritated clients and instructions that quietly go elsewhere. Put a rough value on each before deciding, even if the value is only high, medium or low.
- Continuity. A long-serving receptionist knows which clients are anxious, which agents ring every Friday and which fee earner is in court. That knowledge shortens calls and prevents mistakes, and it walks out of the door when the role goes.
- First impressions. The voice on the phone is often the first contact a new client has with the firm. A warm, informed greeting supports the fee you later quote; a generic one makes the firm sound like every other.
- Fee-earner interruptions. If the outside service cannot answer simple questions about the firm, more calls are put through to fee earners, and each interruption costs focus as well as minutes.
- Complaint risk. Poor communication and delay are the most common complaint types at the Legal Ombudsman[6]. A reception model that leaves callers unsure what happens next feeds both.
- Switching cost. Changing provider later means rewriting scripts, retraining and re-testing escalation, so a cheap first choice can become expensive to undo.
None of these settles the question alone. A firm with very few visitors and most calls out of hours may still be right to outsource. But the decision should be made with these items written down, not discovered six months later.
Compare tasks, not job titles
A receptionist in a solicitors firm rarely just answers calls. Before you compare, list everything the role does and decide who would do each task if the phones moved outside.
| Task | In-house receptionist | Outsourced answering |
|---|---|---|
| Answering calls in the firm's name | Yes | Yes, to the script |
| Taking structured new-enquiry details | Yes, with training | Yes, if the script is matter-specific |
| Meeting and greeting visitors | Yes | No |
| Identity documents for client due diligence | Often | No |
| Post, couriers and document collection | Often | No |
| Diary management for consultations | Yes | Sometimes, with access to a booking system |
| Handling urgent calls | Yes, knows the people | Yes, if the escalation tree is clear |
| Knowing the client who rings every week | Yes | Rarely |
If most of the non-phone tasks would still need a person, the real choice may be a part-time receptionist plus outsourced overflow, rather than one or the other.
Decision criteria
Count your calls and when they arrive
Pull three months of call data. A steady flow through the day suits a person; sharp peaks and out-of-hours volume suit an outside route.
List the non-phone tasks
If visitors, post and ID checks fill half the day, you need someone on site whatever happens to the phones.
Price both options on the same basis
Use the worked method above for the in-house option and the provider's full schedule, including overage and changes, for the outsourced one.
Add the risk column
Confidentiality, data handling and quality of notes are part of the cost. Score each option on them.
Trial before deciding
Put the outside option on overflow for a month and measure note quality and callbacks before moving the main line.
Hybrid models
Many small firms end up with a hybrid: a receptionist for core hours and visitors, an outside route for lunchtime, holidays and early evening, and a direct urgent line for crime or family matters. The hybrid is often cheaper than full in-house cover and safer than full outsourcing, because the person who knows the clients still handles most calls.
Whichever way you go, review the decision after six months with real data: missed calls, complete notes, new enquiries handled, and any complaints about getting through. Our guides to what to check in an answering service and out-of-hours cover cover the next steps.
Frequently asked questions
Is an answering service cheaper than a receptionist for a law firm?
Often for calls alone, but not always once overage, script changes, quality checks and lost instructions are counted. Compare the full cost of each, and remember a receptionist also handles visitors, post and ID checks.
What does a receptionist really cost an employer?
Salary plus employer NIC at 15% above the £5,000 threshold[1], at least the 3% minimum pension contribution[5], holiday cover, recruitment, equipment and management time.
Can we use the Employment Allowance to reduce the cost?
If your firm is eligible, the Employment Allowance can cut your National Insurance bill by up to £10,500 in 2026/27[1]. It applies to the whole payroll, not one role.
Is a hybrid model common?
Yes. Many small firms keep a receptionist for core hours and use an outside route for lunchtime, holidays and early evening.
References
GOV.UK (HMRC) (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Holiday entitlement (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2024). Non-financial business economy, UK: Sections A to S (Annual Business Survey) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Workplace pensions: what you, your employer and the government pay (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑