Phones and call handling

Telephone answering services for solicitors: what to check

The questions to put to a telephone answering service before a solicitors firm signs: confidentiality, scripts, hours, escalation, data handling and exit.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the checks matter more for law firms
  2. Confidentiality and conduct
  3. Data protection terms
  4. Scripts, hours and escalation
  5. What a good message from the service looks like
  6. Running a fair trial
  7. Contract and exit points
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References

Key takeaways

  • The firm stays accountable for compliance when work is carried out through others, including an outside answering service[1].
  • Confidentiality is the first test: the service will hear client affairs that the SRA Code requires you to keep confidential[2].
  • A written processor contract is a legal requirement under UK GDPR, not a nice extra[3].
  • Ask to see the script, a sample message and the escalation procedure before you sign.
  • Run a two-week trial with mystery calls before moving the main line.

Why the checks matter more for law firms

A telephone answering service will speak to your clients, your prospective clients and sometimes the other side, in your firm's name, without anyone from the firm listening. For a plumber or a dental practice, the main risks are a lost booking or a rude call. For a solicitors firm, the risks also include a breach of confidentiality, a caller who believes they have received advice, a missed limitation date, or a conflict that nobody spotted because the other side's name was never taken.

The regulatory position is clear. Under the SRA Code of Conduct for Firms, you remain accountable for compliance with the SRA's regulatory arrangements where your work is carried out through others, including those you contract with[1]. The same Code requires firms to identify, monitor and manage all material risks to the business[1]. An answering service is one of those risks, and the checks below are how you manage it.

Callers also judge the firm by that first voice. In the Legal Services Consumer Panel's 2026 tracker, being a specialist, being regulated and explaining things clearly were the factors most likely to increase consumers' trust in a legal professional[4]. A receptionist who cannot explain what happens next, or who sounds as if they answer for a dozen businesses at once, works against all three.

Factors most likely to increase trust in a legal professionalLegal services consumers in England and Wales, 2026
Factors most likely to increase trust in a legal professionalBar chart. Being a specialist: 92%; Being regulated: 91%; Explaining things clearly: 91%.Being a specialistBeing a specialist: 92%92%Being regulatedBeing regulated: 91%91%Explaining things clearlyExplaining things clearly: 91%91%Factors most likely to increase trust in a legal professionalBar chart. Being a specialist: 92%; Being regulated: 91%; Explaining things clearly: 91%.Being a specialistBeing a specialist: 92%92%Being regulatedBeing regulated: 91%91%Explaining things clearlyExplaining things clearly: 91%91%

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Being a specialist92%
Being regulated91%
Explaining things clearly91%

Confidentiality and conduct

Paragraph 6.3 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors says you keep the affairs of current and former clients confidential unless disclosure is required or permitted by law or the client consents[2]. Every call the service takes may contain exactly those affairs. Ask the provider these questions, and get the answers in writing.

  • Do staff sign confidentiality undertakings, and do those undertakings cover your clients specifically?
  • Are calls handled in an office, at home or overseas, and who can overhear them?
  • Can staff see other clients' scripts and messages, or is access limited by account?
  • Will staff ever confirm to a third party that a person is or is not a client of the firm?
  • How does the service handle a caller who asks for legal advice, and what exact words do staff use?
  • What happens if a member of staff recognises the caller or the matter?

Answering staff should never give a view on the merits of a matter, promise that the firm will act, or quote anything beyond the information the firm has approved. Ask the provider to show you the wording their staff use for 'I can't advise you, but a solicitor will call you back'.

Data protection terms

The service will process personal data on your behalf, often including special category data such as health information in a personal injury enquiry or details of domestic abuse in a family call. Under UK GDPR Article 28, processing by a processor must be governed by a binding contract that sets out the subject matter and duration of the processing, its nature and purpose, the type of personal data and the obligations and rights of the controller[3].

  1. Ask for the provider's standard data processing agreement and check it against Article 28.
  2. Find out where call recordings and notes are stored, and whether any data leaves the UK.
  3. List the sub-processors, such as telephony carriers, transcription tools and CRM platforms.
  4. Agree retention periods for recordings and notes, and how they will be deleted at the end of the contract.
  5. Confirm how quickly the provider will tell you about a personal data breach. Under Article 33, you as controller must notify the ICO without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours of becoming aware of it[5], so the provider's notice period must be much shorter.
  6. Check that your own privacy notice tells callers that an outside service may answer on your behalf.

Scripts, hours and escalation

Most quality problems come from scripts written for a generic small business. Ask for the script the provider would use for you, then rewrite it with them. A good script for a solicitors firm has a short greeting, a set of intake questions for each work type, a clear rule for urgent matters and approved wording for the things staff must not do.

Script and service checks for an answering service
CheckGood answerWarning sign
Script ownershipFirm approves every line; changes made within a working dayProvider uses its own template and charges for every edit
Matter-specific questionsDifferent questions for conveyancing, family, crime and so onOne form for every caller
Conflict informationAlways takes the other party's name for new mattersOnly takes caller details
Urgent callsWritten escalation tree with named contacts and a fallback'We will email you straight away'
HoursCovers the hours you need, including lunch and early eveningOffice hours only, with voicemail after
Message deliveryStructured note to a shared inbox or case system within minutesFree-text emails with no standard fields
Quality reviewRecordings available; regular review callsNo recordings; complaints handled by a general helpdesk

Escalation deserves its own test. Give the provider three realistic urgent scenarios, such as a client who has been arrested, a completion due today with funds missing, and a caller describing domestic abuse. Ask them to walk you through exactly what their staff would do, who they would call, and what happens if that person does not answer.

What a good message from the service looks like

Ask every provider for a real, anonymised sample of a message they sent to another professional services client. Then compare it with the standard you expect. A message your team can act on without ringing the caller to start again usually has the same fields every time, in the same order, so that whoever opens it can allocate it in under a minute.

Example message: New enquiry, family. Caller: Jane Example, mobile ending 214, safe to call after 5 pm, no voicemail. Matter in caller's words: wants to agree child arrangements after separating; no court papers yet. Other party: Mark Example. Deadline: none stated. Urgency: caller said there are no safety concerns. Told: a solicitor will call back tomorrow before 6 pm. Taken by: answering service, 12.41 pm.

Notice what the example does. It records how and when it is safe to call back, which matters in family and employment work. It keeps the caller's own words for the matter rather than a guessed label. It names the other party for the conflict check, records what the caller was promised and shows who took the call and when. If the provider's sample message is a single line of free text, expect the same for your clients.

Agree with the provider that any message missing a required field is flagged as incomplete, and that the service tells the caller honestly what will happen next. A promise that 'someone will call you within the hour' is worse than no promise if your team cannot keep it.

Running a fair trial

  1. Start on overflow only

    Route lunchtime and busy-period overflow to the service for two weeks before moving any main-line traffic.

  2. Make mystery calls

    Ask colleagues or friends to ring with scripted scenarios: a new conveyancing enquiry, an existing client chasing, a caller wanting advice on the spot, and an urgent family call.

  3. Score the notes

    For each call, check whether the note captured the name, number, matter type, deadline, other party and what the caller was told.

  4. Listen to recordings

    Check tone, accuracy and whether staff stuck to the approved wording on advice and confidentiality.

  5. Decide with evidence

    Keep the service only if the notes are as good as your own reception's, and the urgent scenarios were handled correctly.

Example: a five-solicitor firm trialled two answering services on overflow for a fortnight each. One answered faster but missed the other side's name on half the new enquiries; the other was slower to answer but took complete notes and escalated a test arrest call correctly. The firm chose the second, and asked for a shorter answer time as a contract term.

Contract and exit points

Read the contract with the same care you would give a supplier with access to client files, because in practice that is what it is. Look for a minimum term, notice period, any charge for script changes and what happens to your data when the contract ends. Make sure you can take your phone numbers with you; numbers should be ported to you or remain in your name, not held by the service.

Agree service levels you can measure, such as how quickly calls are answered, how quickly messages arrive and how complaints about the service are handled. Then put a review in the diary for three months after go-live. For a wider view of the choice, compare this option with other overflow routes and with the true costs of in-house reception.

Frequently asked questions

Can a solicitors firm use a virtual receptionist?

Yes, but the firm stays accountable for compliance where work is done through others[1], so it needs confidentiality terms, an approved script, a data processing contract and a tested escalation route.

Does an answering service need a data processing agreement?

Yes. UK GDPR Article 28 requires a binding contract between the controller and any processor, covering the subject matter, duration, nature and purpose of the processing[3].

Should the answering service take conflict details?

For new enquiries, yes. At minimum it should take the name of the other party so the firm can run its own conflict check before anyone gives advice.

How long should a trial last?

Two weeks on overflow is usually enough to see note quality and test urgent scenarios with mystery calls before moving the main line.

References

  1. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Firms (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 28: Processor (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 33: Notification of a personal data breach to the supervisory authority (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo